GMAT逻辑解题技巧:Weaken题型总结

来源:GMAT考试    发布时间:2013-01-07    GMAT考试辅导视频    评论

  Weaken解题原理(同Support):定义结论句因果关系, 并确认议题焦点
  正确答案标志:
  - 否定果 (因果关系中的结果不会产生,或是产生相反的结果)
  - 否定因 (另有他因)
  - 因果关系不存在 (决定因果关系的数据错误,样本无代表性,比较基础不同)
  - 倒因为果 (常出现在有survey的题目里,题干中说survey的结果如何如何,故推得一结论,但未考虑survey的对象一开始有具备结果的特质)
  错误答案标志:
  - 补充信息:仅为题干之补充资料,与结论句之因果关系无关。
  - 转移焦点:转移焦点至题干可能提及,或未曾提及之事物,但与题目议题焦点无关。
  - 无关比较:
  * 与结论句无关之两群体比较
  * 有关与无关之两群体比较
  * 有关之群体,拆作两子群体比较
  - 时间焦点错误:
  * 题目未提到时间,答案提到时间
  * 答案提到的时间与题目不一致
  * 提及plan, proposal等未来计划时,提及过去资料作为证据;但过去有效不能证明未来有效
  - 证据力不足:用少数特例作用否定原题论述之根据,常出现下列关键词:(shadow想说:这一条规则有时会出现例外,并不是绝对的> <)
  * some, occationally
  * 关代不当限定
  * 最高级
  * only
  - 不同类型答案:要求weaken,却出现support的答案。
  - 无关模拟:提及他处之案例,以证明原题为真或为非。
  - 扩大范围:题目讨论限定的对象,但答案却提及全体。
  - 极端概念:含有only, 最高级的答案选项,注意是否过于武断。
  - 误用统计数字:比率与总数错误比较,比率高(低)不代表比较多(少)。
  - 违背前提:答案选项违背原题描述的前提。
  例题:
  TN9-Q16:
  Certain genetically modified strains of maize produce a natural insecticide that protects against maize-eating insects. The insecticide occurs throughout the plant, including its pollen.
  Maize pollen is dispersed by the wind and often blows onto milkweed plants that grow near maize fields. Caterpillars of monarch butterflies feed exclusively on milkweed leaves.
  When, in experiments, these caterpillars were fed milkweed leaves dusted with pollen from modified maize plants, they died.
  Therefore, use of the modified maize inadvertently imperils monarch butterflies.
  Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
  首先梳理题目条件:
  (1)有一种经过基因改良的玉米,可以产生一种杀虫成分来抵御虫子。而且这种成分在这种玉米的全身上下各部分都有,连花粉都有
  (2)这种玉米的花粉会被风吹到玉米田旁边的植物上,然后有一种M蝴蝶的幼虫是以该植物的叶子为食的
  (3)在实验室里,喂食沾有转基因玉米花粉的植物叶子的M蝴蝶幼虫都死了
  题目中心论点:这种转基因玉米的使用会无意中危及M蝴蝶
  A.Per unit of volume, the natural insecticide produced by the genetically modified maize plants is less toxic to insects than are many commercial insecticides commonly used on maize plants.
  本选项说同样的量玉米的杀虫剂比商用的杀虫剂毒性弱,属于上面所述的转移焦点(转移焦点至题干可能提及,或未曾提及之事物),与题目论点——玉米会杀M幼虫无关
  B.Standard weed-control practices that have been used by farmers for decades have largely eliminated milkweed plants from certain areas where monarch-butterfly caterpillars were once common.
  本选项说由于控制杂草milkweed在这个地区减少了很多,所以虫子也不剩多少了,同样属于转移焦点,与题目论点无关。
  C.The experiments showed that the caterpillars were not harmed by contact with the pollen from the genetically modified plants unless they ingested it.
  本选项说M幼虫只要不吃花粉就不会死,除此之外爱怎么接触怎么接触,总之就是死不了;说到吃花粉会死,那也就还是玉米会危及M幼虫,支持了结论。但是题目求的是weaken,所以错误啦。
  D.The maize-eating insects that the natural insecticide protects against do not feed on the pollen of the maize plant.
  本选项说吃玉米的虫子不会吃花粉,还是转移焦点,无关题目结论。
  E.Airborne maize pollen tends to collect on the middle leaves of milkweed plants and monarch caterpillars feed only on the plant’s tender upper leaves.
  正解。本选项说花粉会落在中间的叶子上,而M幼虫只会吃上面的叶子,总之一句话,随你怎么飘,就是不吃你。这样一来,虽然玉米花粉飘到milkweed上了,但是M幼虫既没有接触到花粉也没有吃,所以完全不会威胁到生存,也就是否定了题目的果——因果关系中的结果不会产生,故而削弱。
  TN7-Q8:
  Many large department stores in Montalia now provide shopping carts for their customers. Since customers using shopping carts tend to buy more than those without shopping carts, most of these stores are experiencing strong sales growth, while most other department stores are not. Therefore, in order to boost sales, managers of Jerrod’s, Montalia’s premier department store, are planning to purchase shopping carts and make them available to the store’s customers next month.
  Which of the following, if true, casts most doubt whether the managers’ plan, if implemented, will achieve its goal?
  首先还是看题目条件:
  (1)M地很多大型商场现在都为顾客提供手推车
  (2)用手推车的顾客倾向于买更多的东西(shadow想说:难道是因为车子太空了没有购物满足感?),所以提供手推车的这些大型商场现在sales都强力上涨,而其他的商场sales就没有上涨(或者至少没有强力上涨!)
  (3)因此,J商场的经理坐不住了,决定也采购一批手推车,下个月投入使用
  问:哪个选项能削弱J商场经理的决定
  也就是说,题目的中心论点是:采购手推车也能让J商场的sales强力上升,而我们要削弱这一点
  A.Since most customers associate shopping carts with low-quality discount stores, Jerrod’s high-quality image would likely suffer if shopping carts were introduced.
  正解。本选项说了这么个事:鉴于J商场表示自己的货物都是高质量的,不同于其他的低质量折扣店,而大多数顾客认为购物手推车是低质量折扣店才会出现的东西,如果J商场也随大流,其high-quality image将会毁于一旦,所以手推车万万不能引用;我认为这就是否定了题目因果关系中的果,也就是说此因果关系会产生与其他不同的结果,故而削弱了题目中心论点。
  B.Because the unemployment rate has declined to very low levels, Jerrod’s now has to pay significantly higher wages in order to retain its staff.
  本选项说,因为unemployment rate无比非常低,J商场要付更多的工资给员工;跟手推车和sales木有任何关系,转移焦点,无关。
  C.A number of department stores that did not make shopping carts available to their customers have had to close recently due to falling profits.
  本选项说,没有手推车的商场都因为profit下降关门了,(言下之意就是:想升profit吗?想不倒闭吗?赶紧去买手推车吧!)这个选项属于加强题目论点的,所以错误。
  D.Shopping carts are not very expensive, but they generally need to be replaced every few years.
  本选项说手推车是不贵,但是几年就要换一次(话说这个跟sales上升有毛关系啊!);典型的转移焦点,无关选项。
  E.Stores that make shopping carts available to their customers usually have to hire people to retrieve the carts from parking areas.
  本选项说有手推车的商场要雇人到停车场把手推车拿回来,同上,和sales上升木有任何关系,转移焦点,无法削弱。
  以上内容对GMAT逻辑考试中的常见题型及解题技巧进行了详细的讲解,考生可以根据文中重点进行针对性的练习,掌握并熟练应用GMAT逻辑试题的解题思路,从而在GMAT考试中取得好成绩。

视频学习

我考网版权与免责声明

① 凡本网注明稿件来源为"原创"的所有文字、图片和音视频稿件,版权均属本网所有。任何媒体、网站或个人转载、链接转贴或以其他方式复制发表时必须注明"稿件来源:我考网",违者本网将依法追究责任;

② 本网部分稿件来源于网络,任何单位或个人认为我考网发布的内容可能涉嫌侵犯其合法权益,应该及时向我考网书面反馈,并提供身份证明、权属证明及详细侵权情况证明,我考网在收到上述法律文件后,将会尽快移除被控侵权内容。

最近更新

社区交流

考试问答